There is nothing "wrong" with the '84. Most of the people who say "don't buy one" have never owned one. They just heard it from someone who heard it from someone else in the pub one night. To own one is to love one. The fact that the '84 can be considered "bad" only shows how much they improved during the C4's life. I remember when the '84 was released. The fanfare and the hype. This was a clean-sheet design and it was hailed as revolutionary. Remember that it is still the same car now as it was then. The world may have moved on in terms of technology - hell, I think a standard V6 Commodore generates more power now - but when compared with what else was available in the early 80's, it was a rocketship.
There are no actual build or design failures in the car. There are design points that fell-out-of-favour, but no flaws. There are three major areas in which the car is attacked:
1. The suspension is too hard. Yeah, and? If you want a nice supple ride, go and buy a Statesman. I like the ride, and they handle extremely well.
2. The Digital Dash. Personally, I prefer gauges, they are easier to read. But I can live with these. Rumour has it that they are unreliable. Well, mine are nearly 20 years old and working fine. You'll find their most common faults end up being lighting and/or earthing. Be careful with these though. I believe that they can be expensive to have fixed.
3. The Cross-Fire FI. Yep, can't argue with that. It's a crap design. It's major short-coming is in it's port design. They are only about 2/3 the size of the inlet ports in the heads. And it is not possible to make them match without LOTS or grinding and welding. And it is a TBI "wet" manifold design. Outdated and forgotten technology today. There are aftermarket manifolds available, such as the X-Ram (
www.x-ram.com) but the choice is very limited.
Remember though, that it is still a 350. It has potential. You could spend the extra money and buy '86+, but even those were not ball-tearers. You'll probably still end up spending a heap of money making it go hard.
Buy one because you want one, not because the "experts" approve. An '84 is not as good as an '86, that's true. But that in turn is not as good as a '92, and a '96 is better again. That's called evolution. While you're at it, just buy an '03, coz they're better again.
What I'm saying is it is a Corvette and always will be. It is a milestone model in every way. Everyone will try to tell you that one model is better than another, and everyone will have their favourites. Buy an '84, and if it's "reputation" makes it cheaper for you, then that's a win for you. You'll enjoy driving it as much as I enjoy driving mine and never regret your decision.:luv